Globalization and Restorative Justice: in the Thai Criminal
Justice System
Jutharat Ua-amnoey*
A feature television program on channel
11, called "VisaitudKodmai-thai" or "Thai vision on Legal
Matters," is the third strategy in this movement. On the second
and fourth Friday of every month from 11:05 to 12:00 am, people around
the country can learn about interesting and timely issues from ranking
officers in the criminal justice system and from scholars in academic
fields as well.
The promotion of research projects and articles on
restorative justice in the Thai society is the fourth strategy of the
movement. Some research projects are supported by TRF, while others
are dissertations from both law schools and the field of criminal justice.
As a result of these publicized strategies, it took
only two yeas for restorative justice to become recognized in Thailand
and this was the springboard for government interest in this new measure
for victims, offenders, and communities.
The Result of the Movement: Paradigm Shift
in the Thai Criminal Justice
On 10 February 2004, the Cabinet accepted the First National Master
Plan of Criminal Justice 2004-2007, which contains the Restorative Justice
Programs Plan in its Sixth Strategy, "the Strategy to Promote Conciliation
and Diversion from Criminal Justice System. " This is the first
time in Thailand's history that a "National Master Plan of Criminal
Justice" has been adopted, and is also the first time that Restorative
Justice has been incorporated into the Plan and into the mainstream
criminal justice system as well. It seems, then, that the Thai government
is willing to use restorative justice in the criminal justice system.
The Restorative Justice in Thai Praxis
In 2003, the Department of Juvenile Observation and Protection
launched the Family Community Group Conferencing project, which is a
measure of restorative justice, for the first time. By using the Juvenile
Delinquency Act 2534, Article 63, together with the decision of the
prosecutors, 1,972 cases were deferred to restorative justice.
The results showed that the prosecutors were able to defer 1,160 cases
from the mainstream court system and only had to bring 30 cases to trial
(Matichon Newspaper, June 6, 2004). This output shows that 10% of the
juvenile delinquents can learn to show their responsibly to amend their
victims through the restorative justice progress and be removed from
the juvenile court system.
In 2004, the Department of Probation launched a restorative
justice program by the victim-offender mediation model. This pilot project
is in place for the eleven area offices around the country that will
have some output in the upcoming annual budget year. Because of the
limitation of the Criminal Code, probation officers can use restorative
justice only for the pre-investigation stage in the trial process. So,
there is now a movement to amend the law and to propose legislation
for diversion at the prosecution stage.
It can be now said that this social phenomenon, that of restorative
justice has come to the end of its long journey into the Thai criminal
justice system. Restorative justice programs have been initiated in
some offices, which is the beginning of empowering crime victims and
the communities that have neglected for more than a hundred years.
7. Conclusion
To study the rise of restorative justice in Thailand
is to look at how the causes and consequences affected the development
of restorative justice in the Thai criminal justice system and in society
generally. Therefore, I have developed and used a theoretical frame
work. "The Journey of Restorative Justice from the international
Community to the Thai State, Society, and Criminal Justice System, "
to explain this matter. Influential factors can be grouped as both outside-in
and inside-out factors.
The outside-in effect comes from: 1) the international
system or state system that defines the United Nations activities through
UN Crime Congresses every five years; 2) the non-profit international
organizations or global civil societies that are behind the global movement
for restorative justice and the network of NGOs that pushed their governments
and the United Nations to pay attention to crime victims, and communities
by adopting the use of restorative justice in mainstream criminal justice
systems, and 3) the change agents for the Thai criminal justice system
who attended the United Nations' Congress and met with experts and who
then decided to adopt the ideal of restorative justice in Thailand.