If one looks at the world's suppliers of pharmaceuticals, one may categorise countries involved in production into three groups, according to the stages of their manufacturing capability:
-- The major producers are industrialised countries: e.g. Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States. Some developing countries, such as Argentina, Brazil, Egypt, India, Mexico, South Korea, and China, may also be included in this group. Each country mentioned has been able to develop a substantial pharmaceutical industry and is capable of manufacturing NMEs and other raw materials, and even engages in the R&D of new drugs.14
-- A group of middle-level producer states, including Colombia, Kenya, Thailand, and others. These are mainly developing countries with an intermediate stage of manufacturing capability. These countries can produce some pharmaceutical intermediates from raw materials available in the country, and indigenous firms are able to carry out particular types of manufacturing such as formulation and packaging. However, the production of NMEs does not occur. The therapeutic ingredients are mainly imported from countries from the first group above.
-- The countries which have the lowest level of manufacturing capability are heavily dependent on imports of finished drugs to satisfy their health care requirements. Since there is no local formulation or packaging industry, the market shares of foreign firms are very high. A large number of countries belong to this group, including Laos, Cambodia, Costa Rica, and many African states.

Almost 90 per cent of the total value of world pharmaceutical production was accounted for by high income countries.15 The figure shows that the high-income developed countries dominate in world pharmaceutical production. The share of those countries in the value of world pharmaceutical output increased gradually from 89.1 per cent in 1985 to 92.9 per cent in 1999. By contrast, the figures of the world drug production in countries from middle- and low-income countries dropped from 7 and 3.9 per cent in 1985 to 4.5 and 2.6 percent in 1999 respectively.16

Among the high-income countries, the majority of world pharmaceutical production is accounted for by five major countries. The United States has been the biggest producer, accounting for almost one-third of total production (31 per cent), followed by Japan (16 per cent), France (8 per cent), Germany (6 per cent) and the United Kingdom (6 per cent).17

International trade in pharmaceuticals

One of the main features of the pharmaceutical industry is its international operation. Pharmaceutical products can be exported worldwide in various forms: bulk pharmaceuticals for dosage formulations, tablets or capsules in bulk for packaging, or finished packed products ready for use. Many drug companies establish manufacturing subsidiaries, or sales agencies, or both in foreign countries in order to enlarge their market and increase profitability. This characteristic, however, is generally exclusive to large companies. Small firms are inclined to limit their operations within a domestic market. However, in recent years more innovative firms from developing countries have appeared. Generic companies in India and China can now produce active ingredients, and have become the world's most important suppliers of some active ingredients and finished products.18

Despite the emergence of India and China, the world exports of pharmaceutical have been dominated by a few large exporting countries. For instance, Germany, Switzerland, the United States, the United Kingdom and France together accounted for more than one-half of world exports during the last decade.19

Typically, there are two types of companies operating in the pharmaceutical business: research-based and non-research-based companies. The former are large companies, mainly transnational corporations (TNCs). The large companies are carrying out research programmes. Medicines sold by these companies are largely newly invented products arising from successful R&D. Patents will be applied for worldwide as soon as an NME is discovered. Unlike the multinationals, the non-research-based companies, or generally known as generic companies, have a small size. These firms are normally not engaged in R&D, but selling cheaply-priced drugs, so-called generics, which are unable to enjoy patent protection or whose legal protection has expired. Generic firms used to operate within the country of residence, but the situation has been changing recently. India and China have now expanded their operation and become multinational to take advantage of economies of scale.

The world pharmaceutical industry has been dominated by a small number of large TNCs. Although there are many pharmaceutical companies around the world, less than 100 of them make up for the bulk of global drug production and international marketing

  TABLE 1 world's largest pharmaceutical companies by value of sales 1977-2001    
                                                                                
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Company                  Country      Rank 1977  Rank 1985  Rank 1998    Rank  
                                                                                                                    2001  

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pfizer                US                  8          6          5         1    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GlaxoSmithKline       UK/US              --         12         12         2    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Merck                 US                  2          1          1         3    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Astra/Zeneca          Sweden/UK          --         --          4         4    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aventis               France/Germany     --         --          2         5    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bristol-Myers Squibb  US                14-13       10          6         6    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johnson & Johnson     US                 --         --          9         7    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Novartis              Switzerland        --         --          7         8    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upjohn/Pharmacia      US                 11         13         --         9    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wyeth                 US                  6          2         11         10    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eli Lilly             US                 10          9          8         11    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Roche                 Switzerland         5         15         10         12    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bayer                 Germany             3          5          3         13    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Schering-Plough       US                 --         --         14         14    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abbott                US                 --          8         13         15    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Takeda                Japan              15         --         --         16    
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source: WHO, The World Medicines Situation, WHO/EDM/PAR/2004.5, 2004


Footnotes

14. C.C. Tarabusi and G. Vickery, "Globalization in the Pharmaceutical Industry", International Journal of Health Services, Vol.28, No.1, 1998, pp.67- 105.

15. This is based on the World Bank classification of countries according to the level of income as follow: (i) High-income: GNP per capita of US$9,361 or more, (ii) Middle-income: GNP per capita of US$761-9,360, and (iii) Low-income GNP per capita of US$76 or less in 1999.

16. World Health Organisation, The World Medicines Situation, WHO/EDM/PAR/2004.5, 2004.

17. ibid.

18. B. Dhar and C. Rao, "Transfer of Technology for Successful Integration in the Global Economy: A Case Study of Pharmaceutical Industry in India", UNCTAD Investment Policy and Capacity-Building Branch, UNCTAD/ITE/IPRC/Misc.22, 2002.

19. World Health Organisation, The World Medicines Situation, cited above.

 
* This article is published with the kind permission of Jakkrit Kuanpoth, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, University of Wollongong, Australia. This article originally appeared in Intellectual Property Quarterly, No.2, 2007, pp.186-215.
 

 

© Copyright Thailand Law Forum, All Rights Reserved
(except where the work is the individual works of the authors as noted)